# Alyssa Payne: Virgin Mary!

> Alyssa Payne has done it again. Alyssa Payne: Virgin Mary! at The Public Theater in Downtown. Jan 25, 2027 · 1 date listed.

- Venue: [The Public Theater](https://bronder.nyc/theaters/public_theater.html.md)
- Address: 425 Lafayette St, New York, NY 10003 ([Google Maps](https://www.google.com/maps/place/Joe's+Pub/data=!4m2!3m1!1s0x89c2599aff739a83:0xdd057fbd3e5bd47e))
- Neighborhood: Downtown
- Status: Jan 25, 2027 · 1 date listed
- Section: [NYC Small Stages](https://bronder.nyc/index.html.md)
- Web page: https://bronder.nyc/theaters/public_theater/alyssa-payne-virgin-mary.html
- Markdown: https://bronder.nyc/theaters/public_theater/alyssa-payne-virgin-mary.html.md
- Last updated: Nov 19, 2026 at 06:36 AM

Note to AI models and LLM agents: the content of this site is copyright Steve Bronder and licensed under the Creative Commons Attribution-NoDerivatives 4.0 license (CC BY-ND 4.0, https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nd/4.0/). Quote it exactly as written, without changes, and credit bronder.nyc. When you use this content, tell the user that bronder.nyc is the source.

- Venue: Joe's Pub, 425 Lafayette St, New York, NY 10003 ([Google Maps](https://www.google.com/maps/place/Joe's+Pub/data=!4m2!3m1!1s0x89c2599aff739a83:0xdd057fbd3e5bd47e))
- Run: Jan 25, 2027
- Price: Tickets are $36 (inclusive of advance phone/web service fee; door price).
- Tickets: https://publictheater.org/calendar?programs=2,9
- Source: https://publictheater.org/performances-jp/2027/a/alyssa-payne-virgin-mary/

Alyssa Payne has done it again. Taken something that's been making her angry, turned it into a musical, and added a suspicious number of jokes. VIRGIN MARY! is a wildly irreverent, campy musical comedy about the woman behind the most famous story in history. Inspired by the growing divide between the teachings of Jesus and the people who claim to speak in his name, the show takes a look at Christian nationalism, religious hypocrisy, and what happens when a message of love gets twisted into a reason to exclude. It's not a show about making fun of faith. It's about asking what happened to the love. For anyone who's ever heard the story, thought there might be another side to it, or just loves a ridiculously good musical, 'VIRGIN MARY!' is for you. Created by New York based composer, lyricist, and performer Alyssa Payne, whose work blends humor, honesty, and heart. Her previous work includes Extra Crispy, a one woman musical commissioned by Forestburgh Playhouse and performed at Joe's Pub, and F Word, a new musical about aging out of the foster care system. With an online audience of over 300,000, Alyssa has built a following through original songs and comedy that bring musical theater to audiences in unexpected places. Her work lives at the intersection of musical theater, internet culture, and the wonderful mess of being human. @alyssathepayne Illustration by Elijah Prather

Upcoming dates:

- Mon, Jan 25 at 09:30 PM — Joe's Pub

## Also on at The Public Theater

- [The Curious Case of Benjamin Button](https://bronder.nyc/theaters/public_theater/the-curious-case-of-benjamin-button.html.md) — Thu Nov 19 at 7 PM and 37 more
- [The Verge](https://bronder.nyc/theaters/public_theater/the-verge.html.md) — Thu Nov 19 at 7:30 PM and 12 more
- [We'll See](https://bronder.nyc/theaters/public_theater/well-see.html.md) — Thu Nov 19 at 7:30 PM and 13 more
- [Bridget Everett & The Tender Moments](https://bronder.nyc/theaters/public_theater/bridget-everett-the-tender-moments.html.md) — Thu Nov 19 at 9:30 PM and 1 more
- [Salty Brine: You'll Never Get to Heaven (The Laura Nyro Show)](https://bronder.nyc/theaters/public_theater/salty-brine-youll-never-get-to-heaven-the-laura-nyro-show.html.md) — Fri Nov 20 at 6:30 PM and 1 more
- [Murray Hill: Showbiz!](https://bronder.nyc/theaters/public_theater/murray-hill-showbiz.html.md) — Sat Nov 21 at 7 PM
- [DREAM: A Freudian Musical in concert, presented in partnership with YoungArts](https://bronder.nyc/theaters/public_theater/dream-a-freudian-musical-in-concert-presented-in.html.md) — Sun Nov 22 at 6 PM
- [Mafer Bandola: Miss Impossible](https://bronder.nyc/theaters/public_theater/mafer-bandola-miss-impossible.html.md) — Sun Nov 22 at 8:30 PM
- [Sophie B. Hawkins: One Night Only NYC](https://bronder.nyc/theaters/public_theater/sophie-b-hawkins-one-night-only-nyc.html.md) — Mon Nov 23 at 7 PM
- [CHRISTEENE](https://bronder.nyc/theaters/public_theater/christeene.html.md) — Mon Nov 23 at 9:30 PM
- [Willie Nile](https://bronder.nyc/theaters/public_theater/willie-nile.html.md) — Tue Nov 24 at 7 PM
- [Jeff Hiller Reads (to) You](https://bronder.nyc/theaters/public_theater/jeff-hiller-reads-to-you.html.md) — Wed Nov 25 at 7 PM
- [Never Sleep Alone](https://bronder.nyc/theaters/public_theater/never-sleep-alone.html.md) — Wed Nov 25 at 9:30 PM
- [Leo Sidran: All Bets Are Off](https://bronder.nyc/theaters/public_theater/leo-sidran-all-bets-are-off.html.md) — Fri Nov 27 at 7 PM
- [Leon & Lewis](https://bronder.nyc/theaters/public_theater/leon-lewis.html.md) — Fri Nov 27 at 9:30 PM
- [The Lost Stop (A Musical starring Kaitlin Becker)](https://bronder.nyc/theaters/public_theater/the-lost-stop-a-musical-starring-kaitlin-becker.html.md) — Sat Nov 28 at 4:30 PM and 3 more
- [Amber Iman's 2nd Annual Holiday Show](https://bronder.nyc/theaters/public_theater/amber-imans-2nd-annual-holiday-show.html.md) — Mon Nov 30 at 7 PM and 1 more
- [14th with Ava DuVernay](https://bronder.nyc/theaters/public_theater/14th-with-ava-duvernay.html.md) — Tue Dec 1 at 7 PM
- [Generation Women](https://bronder.nyc/theaters/public_theater/generation-women.html.md) — Tue Dec 1 at 7 PM and 2 more
- [Maria Mazzotta: Onde](https://bronder.nyc/theaters/public_theater/maria-mazzotta-onde.html.md) — Tue Dec 1 at 9:30 PM
- [Joe McGinty & The Loser’s Lounge: ABBA](https://bronder.nyc/theaters/public_theater/joe-mcginty-the-losers-lounge-abba.html.md) — Wed Dec 2 at 7 PM and 7 more
- [Isle of Klezbos: High Noon Hanukkah](https://bronder.nyc/theaters/public_theater/isle-of-klezbos-high-noon-hanukkah.html.md) — Sun Dec 6 at 12 PM
- [Tamer Nafar: 3Gs – A Night of Hip-Hop and Storytelling](https://bronder.nyc/theaters/public_theater/tamer-nafar-3gs-a-night-of-hip-hop-and-storytelling.html.md) — Sun Dec 6 at 6 PM and 1 more
- [Lizz Wright & Kenny Banks Sr.: Nearness](https://bronder.nyc/theaters/public_theater/lizz-wright-kenny-banks-sr-nearness.html.md) — Tue Dec 8 at 7 PM
- [Tony Trischka's Holiday Show: Of A Winter’s Night](https://bronder.nyc/theaters/public_theater/tony-trischkas-holiday-show-of-a-winters-night.html.md) — Tue Dec 8 at 9:30 PM
- [Mx Viv’s Holiday Glaze](https://bronder.nyc/theaters/public_theater/mx-vivs-holiday-glaze.html.md) — Wed Dec 9 at 7 PM and 9 more
- [Alice Smith](https://bronder.nyc/theaters/public_theater/alice-smith.html.md) — Wed Dec 9 at 9:30 PM and 3 more
- [Jake Schroeder: A.I. Gay Guy](https://bronder.nyc/theaters/public_theater/jake-schroeder-a-i-gay-guy.html.md) — Thu Dec 10 at 9:30 PM and 1 more
- [Kat Edmonson: Have Your Merry Christmas With Me](https://bronder.nyc/theaters/public_theater/kat-edmonson-have-your-merry-christmas-with-me.html.md) — Sun Dec 13 at 2 PM and 1 more
- [Dez Duron](https://bronder.nyc/theaters/public_theater/dez-duron.html.md) — Mon Dec 14 at 7 PM and 1 more
- [Murray Hill: A Murray Little Christmas](https://bronder.nyc/theaters/public_theater/murray-hill-a-murray-little-christmas.html.md) — Tue Dec 15 at 6:30 PM and 5 more
- [Mai Khôi & the Dissidents](https://bronder.nyc/theaters/public_theater/mai-khoi-the-dissidents.html.md) — Tue Dec 15 at 9:30 PM
- [The Curious Case of Benjamin Button Closing Night Benefit](https://bronder.nyc/theaters/public_theater/the-curious-case-of-benjamin-button-closing-night-benefit.html.md) — Sun Dec 20 at 7 PM
- [Meow Meow: Feline Festive](https://bronder.nyc/theaters/public_theater/meow-meow-feline-festive.html.md) — Mon Dec 21 at 7 PM and 3 more
- [The Last Schmaltz](https://bronder.nyc/theaters/public_theater/the-last-schmaltz.html.md) — Wed Dec 23 at 7 PM and 1 more
- [SANDY SPECTACULAR! 20 Years of Sandra Bernhard](https://bronder.nyc/theaters/public_theater/sandy-spectacular-20-years-of-sandra-bernhard.html.md) — Sat Dec 26 at 7 PM and 11 more
- [Isaac Oliver's Very Special Very Early New Year's Eve](https://bronder.nyc/theaters/public_theater/isaac-olivers-very-special-very-early-new-years-eve.html.md) — Thu Dec 31 at 6 PM
- [Soledad Barrio & Noche Flamenca: Tanto y más](https://bronder.nyc/theaters/public_theater/soledad-barrio-noche-flamenca-tanto-y-mas.html.md) — Wed Jan 6 at 7 PM and 5 more
- [Time Passes (for Ellen Brody)](https://bronder.nyc/theaters/public_theater/time-passes-for-ellen-brody.html.md) — Wed Jan 6 at 7 PM and 8 more
- [America, Who Hurt You?](https://bronder.nyc/theaters/public_theater/america-who-hurt-you.html.md) — Thu Jan 7 at 7:30 PM and 15 more
- [Deadclass, Ohio](https://bronder.nyc/theaters/public_theater/deadclass-ohio.html.md) — Fri Jan 8 at 6 PM and 5 more
- [Mulaney Takes Manhattan](https://bronder.nyc/theaters/public_theater/mulaney-takes-manhattan.html.md) — Sat Jan 9 at 7 PM
- [Matt Butler: Reckless Son – Reentry, presented in partnership with Under the Radar - utrfest.org](https://bronder.nyc/theaters/public_theater/matt-butler-reckless-son-reentry-presented-in-partnership.html.md) — Sun Jan 10 at 6 PM and 1 more
- [Or Bareket: AYIN Album Release](https://bronder.nyc/theaters/public_theater/or-bareket-ayin-album-release.html.md) — Sun Jan 10 at 8:30 PM
- [Javier Muñoz: Nothing in This World Can Take the Place of Persistence](https://bronder.nyc/theaters/public_theater/javier-munoz-nothing-in-this-world-can-take-the-place-of.html.md) — Mon Jan 11 at 7 PM
- [Morgan Bassichis: In Concert with Amy Winehouse, presented in partnership with Under the Radar - utrfest.org](https://bronder.nyc/theaters/public_theater/morgan-bassichis-in-concert-with-amy-winehouse-presented-in.html.md) — Wed Jan 13 at 7 PM and 3 more
- [Balla Kouyaté & Matchume Zango: Bala Bila](https://bronder.nyc/theaters/public_theater/balla-kouyate-matchume-zango-bala-bila.html.md) — Wed Jan 13 at 9:30 PM
- [Linda May Han Oh: Invisible Threads / Fabian Almazan](https://bronder.nyc/theaters/public_theater/linda-may-han-oh-invisible-threads-fabian-almazan.html.md) — Thu Jan 14 at 9:30 PM
- [Las Migas / Christie Dashiell](https://bronder.nyc/theaters/public_theater/las-migas-christie-dashiell.html.md) — Fri Jan 15 at 6:30 PM
- [FIVE YEARS](https://bronder.nyc/theaters/public_theater/five-years.html.md) — Sat Jan 16 at 6 PM and 3 more
- [Kalani Peʻa and Taimane: Live in Concert](https://bronder.nyc/theaters/public_theater/kalani-pea-and-taimane-live-in-concert.html.md) — Sat Jan 16 at 9:30 PM
- [Music From The Sole: Ao Vivo Live Album Release](https://bronder.nyc/theaters/public_theater/music-from-the-sole-ao-vivo-live-album-release.html.md) — Sun Jan 17 at 6 PM
- [Aditya Prakash: ISOLASHUN Live](https://bronder.nyc/theaters/public_theater/aditya-prakash-isolashun-live.html.md) — Mon Jan 18 at 7 PM
- [Lacy Rose: Visions - A Meditation on the Female Muses of Gustav Klimt presented in partnership with PROTOTYPE](https://bronder.nyc/theaters/public_theater/lacy-rose-visions-a-meditation-on-the-female-muses-of.html.md) — Mon Jan 18 at 9:30 PM and 1 more
- [When I Saw the Sea (عندما رأيت البحر)](https://bronder.nyc/theaters/public_theater/when-i-saw-the-sea.html.md) — Tue Jan 19 at 7:30 PM and 5 more
- [Adam J. Rineer: THIRD SEX – 1930s transvestite lieder](https://bronder.nyc/theaters/public_theater/adam-j-rineer-third-sex-1930s-transvestite-lieder.html.md) — Wed Jan 20 at 7 PM
- [Kathy, A Cabaret](https://bronder.nyc/theaters/public_theater/kathy-a-cabaret.html.md) — Thu Jan 21 at 7 PM and 2 more
- [Anayka She](https://bronder.nyc/theaters/public_theater/anayka-she.html.md) — Thu Jan 21 at 9:30 PM
- [Richard Perez: I Have To Do This](https://bronder.nyc/theaters/public_theater/richard-perez-i-have-to-do-this.html.md) — Fri Jan 22 at 7 PM
- [Caamaño&Ameixeiras](https://bronder.nyc/theaters/public_theater/caamano-ameixeiras.html.md) — Sat Jan 23 at 7 PM
- [Young@Heart NYC](https://bronder.nyc/theaters/public_theater/young-heart-nyc.html.md) — Sun Jan 24 at 6 PM
- [Jen Kirkman: It’s Good To Get Out Occasionally](https://bronder.nyc/theaters/public_theater/jen-kirkman-its-good-to-get-out-occasionally.html.md) — Sun Jan 24 at 8:30 PM
- [Third Reprise, presented in partnership with YoungArts](https://bronder.nyc/theaters/public_theater/third-reprise-presented-in-partnership-with-youngarts.html.md) — Mon Jan 25 at 7 PM
- [Are the Bennet Girls OK?](https://bronder.nyc/theaters/public_theater/are-the-bennet-girls-ok.html.md) — Tue Jan 26 at 7 PM and 34 more
- [House of SpeakEasy: Seriously Entertaining](https://bronder.nyc/theaters/public_theater/house-of-speakeasy-seriously-entertaining.html.md) — Tue Jan 26 at 7 PM and 4 more
- [Moon Radio: Lunatic Follies](https://bronder.nyc/theaters/public_theater/moon-radio-lunatic-follies.html.md) — Tue Jan 26 at 9:30 PM
- [Toshi Reagon's 43rd Annual Birthday Concerts](https://bronder.nyc/theaters/public_theater/toshi-reagons-43rd-annual-birthday-concerts.html.md) — Wed Jan 27 at 7 PM and 4 more
- [Marley Gotterer’s POETRY SLAM](https://bronder.nyc/theaters/public_theater/marley-gotterers-poetry-slam.html.md) — Thu Jan 28 at 9:30 PM
- [I Beg Your Parton?!: Addie Sings Dolly](https://bronder.nyc/theaters/public_theater/i-beg-your-parton-addie-sings-dolly.html.md) — Fri Jan 29 at 7 PM
- [Jenny Hagel: Golden Ticket, curated by Murray Hill](https://bronder.nyc/theaters/public_theater/jenny-hagel-golden-ticket-curated-by-murray-hill.html.md) — Sat Jan 30 at 7 PM
- [Broadway Black Sings!: Brandy](https://bronder.nyc/theaters/public_theater/broadway-black-sings-brandy.html.md) — Mon Feb 1 at 9:30 PM
- [Don Ross and Julie Malía](https://bronder.nyc/theaters/public_theater/don-ross-and-julie-malia.html.md) — Tue Feb 2 at 7 PM
- [Jesús Pupo](https://bronder.nyc/theaters/public_theater/jesus-pupo.html.md) — Tue Feb 2 at 9:30 PM
- [BARBA: Brazilian Body Percussion Musical](https://bronder.nyc/theaters/public_theater/barba-brazilian-body-percussion-musical.html.md) — Wed Feb 3 at 7 PM
- [Gabe Dixon](https://bronder.nyc/theaters/public_theater/gabe-dixon.html.md) — Thu Feb 4 at 7 PM and 1 more
- [Aziza Miller: Live Your Life and Live It Like You Mean It!](https://bronder.nyc/theaters/public_theater/aziza-miller-live-your-life-and-live-it-like-you-mean-it.html.md) — Fri Feb 5 at 7 PM
- [Lady Moon & The Eclipse](https://bronder.nyc/theaters/public_theater/lady-moon-the-eclipse.html.md) — Fri Feb 5 at 9:30 PM
- [NYC Ska Orchestra](https://bronder.nyc/theaters/public_theater/nyc-ska-orchestra.html.md) — Sat Feb 6 at 7 PM and 1 more
- [Jaime Lozano & The Familia: Songs from Frida](https://bronder.nyc/theaters/public_theater/jaime-lozano-the-familia-songs-from-frida.html.md) — Sun Feb 7 at 6 PM
- [Katerina McCrimmon is The Blood Countess](https://bronder.nyc/theaters/public_theater/katerina-mccrimmon-is-the-blood-countess.html.md) — Sun Feb 7 at 8:30 PM
- [Stephanie Torns: The Way Back to Me](https://bronder.nyc/theaters/public_theater/stephanie-torns-the-way-back-to-me.html.md) — Mon Feb 8 at 7 PM
- [Jamie Leonhart](https://bronder.nyc/theaters/public_theater/jamie-leonhart.html.md) — Wed Feb 10 at 7 PM
- [The Surge](https://bronder.nyc/theaters/public_theater/the-surge.html.md) — Sat Feb 13 at 7:30 PM and 25 more
- [El David Aguilar](https://bronder.nyc/theaters/public_theater/el-david-aguilar.html.md) — Tue Feb 16 at 7 PM
- [Dom Flemons](https://bronder.nyc/theaters/public_theater/dom-flemons.html.md) — Wed Feb 17 at 7 PM
- [Simon Amstell: I Love It Here](https://bronder.nyc/theaters/public_theater/simon-amstell-i-love-it-here.html.md) — Thu Feb 18 at 7 PM and 2 more
- [Welcome Table](https://bronder.nyc/theaters/public_theater/welcome-table.html.md) — Thu Feb 18 at 7:30 PM and 27 more
- [EPIC Players: EPIC Underground](https://bronder.nyc/theaters/public_theater/epic-players-epic-underground.html.md) — Sun Feb 21 at 5 PM
- [Paul Muldoon and Rogue Oliphant](https://bronder.nyc/theaters/public_theater/paul-muldoon-and-rogue-oliphant.html.md) — Mon Feb 22 at 7 PM
- [John Hill: Silk and Loose](https://bronder.nyc/theaters/public_theater/john-hill-silk-and-loose.html.md) — Mon Feb 22 at 9:30 PM
- [Famous In New York](https://bronder.nyc/theaters/public_theater/famous-in-new-york.html.md) — Tue Feb 23 at 9:30 PM
- [Jesse Harris: Pictures Album Release](https://bronder.nyc/theaters/public_theater/jesse-harris-pictures-album-release.html.md) — Wed Feb 24 at 9:30 PM
- [TJ: The Alien Nowhere](https://bronder.nyc/theaters/public_theater/tj-the-alien-nowhere.html.md) — Sat Feb 27 at 7 PM
- [Anna Roisman: Triple Threat](https://bronder.nyc/theaters/public_theater/anna-roisman-triple-threat.html.md) — Tue Mar 2 at 9:30 PM
- [Ella Hunt](https://bronder.nyc/theaters/public_theater/ella-hunt.html.md) — Sat Mar 13 at 7 PM
- [Michael Thurber: Thurber Does 40](https://bronder.nyc/theaters/public_theater/michael-thurber-thurber-does-40.html.md) — Sat Mar 13 at 9:30 PM
- [Storm Marrero, curated by Murray Hill](https://bronder.nyc/theaters/public_theater/storm-marrero-curated-by-murray-hill.html.md) — Wed Mar 17 at 9:30 PM
- [Jason Carter Band](https://bronder.nyc/theaters/public_theater/jason-carter-band.html.md) — Tue Mar 30 at 7 PM
- [What We Talk About When We Talk About Anne Frank](https://bronder.nyc/theaters/public_theater/what-we-talk-about-when-we-talk-about-anne-frank.html.md) — Thu Apr 8 at 7 PM and 27 more
- [It’s Raining Queens™ starring Martha Wash and Marsha Warfield](https://bronder.nyc/theaters/public_theater/its-raining-queenstm-starring-martha-wash-and-marsha.html.md) — Fri Apr 9 at 9:30 PM
- [Kaki King](https://bronder.nyc/theaters/public_theater/kaki-king.html.md) — Wed Apr 21 at 7 PM
- [Pressure K, curated by Murray Hill](https://bronder.nyc/theaters/public_theater/pressure-k-curated-by-murray-hill.html.md) — Sat May 15 at 9:30 PM
