About me

Alyssa Payne: Virgin Mary!

Spotify: Alyssa Payne

Joe's Pub · Downtown

425 Lafayette St, New York, NY 10003Maps ↗ to Joe's PubWebsite ↗ of Joe's Pub

January 25, 20271 date listed

Updated

Choose a time for tickets, or + to add it to your itinerary.

  • January 25, 2027

    Alyssa Payne has done it again. Taken something that's been making her angry, turned it into a musical, and added a suspicious number of jokes. VIRGIN MARY! is a wildly irreverent, campy musical comedy about the woman behind the most famous story in history. Inspired by the growing divide between the teachings of Jesus and the people who claim to speak in his name, the show takes a look at Christian nationalism, religious hypocrisy, and what happens when a message of love gets twisted into a reason to exclude. It's not a show about making fun of faith. It's about asking what happened to the love. For anyone who's ever heard the story, thought there might be another side to it, or just loves a ridiculously good musical, 'VIRGIN MARY!' is for you. Created by New York based composer, lyricist, and performer Alyssa Payne, whose work blends humor, honesty, and heart. Her previous work includes Extra Crispy, a one woman musical commissioned by Forestburgh Playhouse and performed at Joe's Pub, and F Word, a new musical about aging out of the foster care system. With an online audience of over 300,000, Alyssa has built a following through original songs and comedy that bring musical theater to audiences in unexpected places. Her work lives at the intersection of musical theater, internet culture, and the wonderful mess of being human. @alyssathepayne Illustration by Elijah Prather

    Upcoming Dates

Joe's Pub

Also on at Joe's Pub

Your itinerary

Nothing saved yet. Choose + beside a showtime to start building a night out.

Back to the list

Know a place we’re missing?

Help this guide find its next small stage, jazz room, or gallery. Send a venue you’d like to see here.